Educators Will Work Without Paychecks to Keep Broke District From Failing

When Bonita Davis’ husband passed away in August, she faced the same fears and anxieties that would grip any new single parent. The bills didn’t stop coming. She wondered how she would continue supporting her two children in college.

And Davis, a sixth-grade teacher in the Chester Upland School District in Chester, PA, had no idea how much worse things were about to get.

Chester Upland, one of the poorest districts in Pennsylvania, made the stunning announcement in December that, without an infusion of cash from the state, it could no longer make payroll – starting with employees’ January 18th checks. Devastating state budget cuts had rendered the district destitute and had left its teachers, support professionals and administrators with two choices – find other employment, or continue showing up to work with no certainty of when they would be paid as promised.

“In the 27 years I’ve been here, I’ve never had to worry about the possibility of a job that wouldn’t exist or children who wouldn’t have a stable place to go,” Davis said. “We’re worried about not existing.”

Fears of a mass employee exodus and school closings quickly swept through the community, and educators were inundated daily with questions from students about whether the schools would be open the following day. And that’s when something heroic happened.

At an early January meeting, members of the Chester Upland Education Association and the Chester Upland Education Support Personnel Association, affiliates of the Pennsylvania State Education Association and the National Education Association, passed a resolution promising to stay on the job – even without pay – as long as they were individually able. The teachers and support professionals vowed to band together to keep the schools running for as long as they could.

“I was never so proud in my life to be a PSEA member, to be a CUEA member,” said Columbus Elementary math teacher Sara Ferguson, a third-generation teacher in Chester Upland. “Everyone has different financial situations, but … we decided to remain on the job as professionals.”

Audio: Columbus Elementary Teacher Sara Ferguson Discusses the Vote by Teachers and Support Professionals to Remain on the Job.

Understanding the Decision


Chester Upland’s educators understand that skipping pay checks doesn’t jibe with typical American notions of fairplay, or economists’ notions of “rationality.” But working for the district has always been about more than money – it’s a calling.

Chester Upland is one of the poorest districts in Pennsylvania – and the pay reflects that. Education support professionals and teachers earn considerably less than their peers in neighboring districts.

The pay may be low in Chester, but the stakes are unbelievably high. Drugs, poverty and gang-related violence have left a trail of hardship and heartbreak across the city. In 2010 Chester had the highest murder rate in Pennsylvania, and just 18 months ago the city was operating under a state of emergency after a rash of violence.

Chester Upland’s educators are more than teachers, nurses, librarians, custodians and assistants – they are players in a daily drama focused on keeping kids in schools and away from destructive influences. Working without a pay check is hard to imagine – but allowing Chester Upland’s schools to close is unacceptable.

“We need the students to know that we’re here and we’re not abandoning them,” Ferguson said. “We need them to know they’ll have some place to go.”

Educators say the fear of being abandoned is running rampant among students, many of whom have learned about the district’s financial hardships through news reports and community chatter. As students walk past the shuttered businesses and abandoned homes that dot many of the streets of Chester, they are reminded daily that people sometimes leave. The city has lost 12 percent of its population since 1990, and kids worry that  teachers and support staff will be next to go.

“That’s why we have to keep showing up,” said middle school math teacher Fran Santoleri. “It gives them stability.”

What’s Next?

As Chester Upland’s finances go up in smoke, the district finds itself in the unenviable position of turning for help to the man who lit the match – Governor Tom Corbett. Corbett cut $860 million from public education, ignoring warnings that poor districts, which lack a tax base to offset aid cuts, would be disproportionately affected.

“Our city does not have a great revenue base,” said John Shelton, who has been teaching in the district for 17 years and is a CUEA vice president. “Anything that hurts revenue hurts the kids.”

Corbett’s “let them eat cake” education budget has wreaked havoc in low-income districts across the state, and shortchanged Chester Upland by $8.4 million this year. Compounding that problem, nearly 45 percent of Chester Upland’s funding is used to support two charter schools. The Corbett administration has thus far rejected appeals from the district for an advance on state subsidy payments, suggesting that Chester Upland has a history of mismanagement.

But the district was under state control until 2010, and operated during the 2010-2011 school year under a state-crafted budget. The district’s elected board prepared the budget only for the current year, and has had control of the district’s finances only since last summer.

No one can accuse Chester Upland of hoarding money. The district laid off 40 percent of its teachers and half its unionized support staff before the start of the year, leading some class sizes to balloon to more than 40 students. Buildings are outdated and students need basic materials and supplies.

“The kids in Chester Upland don’t get the same opportunities as the kids in other communities,” said Jacqueline Browne, a district administrative assistant and leader of the support staff union.

Amazingly, for all its talk about bringing accountability to Pennsylvania’s schools, Corbett’s administration can’t wash its hands fast enough of the mess it made in Chester Upland, and it’s unclear whether relief is ever coming. Acting Deputy Superintendent Thomas Persing said it’s time for all the adults involved to forget the politics and do what’s right for kids. Chester Upland provides students with more than an education – in many cases, the district provides the only meal kids eat all day.

“Children won’t just go hungry for an education,” Persing said. “They’ll go hungry physically.”

The teachers and support professionals of Chester Upland are doing everything in their power to prevent that – but it’s not easy. If they are heroes, they’d prefer not to be – they want to do right by their students, but are understandably frightened of losing their homes or being unable to provide for their families.

“As long as I can use my reserves and keep a roof over my family, I’ll stay. I’m in it for the long haul,” Shelton said. “But we need help.  We need serious help.”

Chester Upland Teacher Invited to Attend 2012 State of the Union Address

  • Tiffani

    What an inspiration to all teachers!

  • Jon

    This unified initiative is admirable, but it is also the kind of action that makes state beaurocrats think they can get away with this overt underfunding.

    Poperty Tax is an outdated and inequitable way of funding public schools. Only state Robin Hood laws can remedy this problem. PA needs to get right with its citizens.

    I hate to say it, but I would have packed my bags. I can’t pay the mortgage with good intentions.

    Also, Charter Schools are money sucking Monsters that should be outlawed. That money belongs to the real public schools, not private schools perpetrating a public fraud.

  • Marlene Giese

    Are the Principals and the Superintendents or the Financial Managers offering ANY of their salary? Teachers get the blame, but Principals, Superintendents, and Financial Managers get much higher salaries than teachers. No, they don’t belong to a union. But they get health benefits and pensions. Why has no one brought them into the picture? I admire what these teachers are doing. Will they be able to keep it up? Probably not. There will be more people on public assistance in an already stressed district.

  • Karen Contreras

    Perhaps some NEA funds could be used to help these teachers. I really do appreciate all that the NEA does and I don’t mind paying my dues. I’d mind even less if some dues money helped support these teachers.

  • Pingback: Education Votes()

  • Sara

    I’m glad to see an article that points out the gasoline in this fire, the huge budget cuts and a state leader that refuses to listen to educators. If only the news stations on TV would actually focus on that part of the story.

  • Jon

    Every penny the teachers don’t get paid, but that they work, should be written off on their state taxes as charity volunteer hours.

  • Pingback: Pennsylvania school district runs out of money to pay teachers, but they keep teaching | Hotspyer – Breaking News from around the web()

  • Pingback: Pennsylvania school district runs out of money to pay teachers, but they keep teaching | FavStocks()

  • Sande Wendt

    Is there a fund set up anywhere to help these teachers? I’d gladly contribute.

  • Pingback: Pennsylvania school district runs out of money to pay teachers, but they keep teaching | TeaBaggers Of America()

  • K Gilmore

    Someone needs to file a lawsuit against the state on behalf of the children and teachers from Chester Upland. This situation is a disservice on many levels. The Goveror should be ashamed of himself. And replaced by someone with a brain. People can’t afford to work for free- teachers need to pay their bills too. How do 2 schools get 45% of the budget?

  • Pingback: Teachers Work Without Pay in Pennsylvania « educationclearinghouse()

  • colette clancy

    These teachers are very brave. Teachers are the advocates for students and the public education system in America, not the Republican party. This is exactly what they want to happen to public schools. Choking them and the children and families who comprise the community around this school. This is a warning and a clear attack upon the poor, the struggling and the middle class. The message against them is “give up” our money and politics will always win.
    Hey Govenor Cuomo, how about those teachers do they rate as “highly effective”?

  • Pingback: “They used to make film there, no?” – Moving from Kodak to college | Bear On The Couch Productions()

  • Las

    How could NEA support teachers not getting paid? Yes teaching is a calling but we don’t need to take a vow of poverty. Teachers are also home owners, parents that want to send their own kids to college, tax payers and customers supporting local economies. I commend the teachers for not wanting to abandon students that already have so many obstacles to overcome but this will reinforce politicians devaluing educators and all we do. May the decision makers come to their Seneca and find the money to support the people holding up the community.

  • bill merritt

    Working for free may be heroic, but who are kidding here? It only serves to allow dim-witted, self promoting politicians to tighten the financial noose further. My prayers to everyone choose to perpetuate this issue. Really, is there ever a year in which funding salary increases is not a problem?
    It will never change until educators and classified staff gain total support of the parent/taxpayers of which there seems to be fewer each year.

  • Peggy Franz

    I can sympathize with these teachers. I would not want to abandon my students either, but I don’t want them being held up as proof that teachers can and will work for less. I wonder if these teachers will lose their jobs in a few years when their students don’t meet standards?

  • Karen

    Why are you promoting this? You should be ashamed–and you should be outraged on behalf of the teachers of that district.

  • Pingback: These Educators Deserve a Movie Deal - Lily's Blackboard – Lily's Blackboard()

  • Pingback: Education Votes()

  • Miriam Aguilar Escobar

    Heroes? Although for some critics, this type of action might look as a solution to this school, these group of good teachers are only supporting the status quo, that continue stealing resources from our students. Our government should be responsible for our communities, it is unconstitutional not to provide with funds for education. Are the superintendent, principals also working for free? Is Arnie Duncan working for free? His salary needs to be detained until our schools are fully funded. Why do we need a Superintendent of Education, when he does not care for our schools to continue to be open? We have accepted furlough everywhere, and still have the responsibility to teach the whole curriculum. We, are doing our fair share of the pain, but for NEA to glorify working for free is not appropriate, unless you pay for my gas,electric bills, and housing expenses, and my educational loans.

  • Pingback: These Educators Deserve a Movie Deal « MomsRising Blog()

  • Pingback: Blue Mass Group | Grover’s Pigs()

  • Pingback: Grover Norquist: The Bay State’s Burden |()

  • I’m extremely inspired together with your writing abilities and also with the layout to your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you modify it yourself? Anyway keep up the nice quality writing, it’s rare to see a nice blog like this one today.