Religious Right Using After-School Clubs to Undermine Public Education, Says Author

For many anti-public education activists, maybe, as the saying goes, “nothing succeeds like failure.” Extremist agendas are usually more about undermining, or even dismantling, the institution they want to “reform.”  Journalist Katherine Stewart sees such a dynamic at work with the Religious Right and its aggressive and increasingly successful campaign to install so-called “Good News Clubs” in schools across America. In a nation as diverse as ours, a plan to transform public schools into fundamentalist boot camps is bound to ultimately fail. But, says Stewart, much can be accomplished along the way to chip away at the institution and exhaust and frustrate its supporters.

Stewart’s book, “The Good News Club: The Christian Right’s Stealth Assault on America’s Children” investigates a specific brand of after-school bible study programs (called “Good News Clubs”) that have proliferated across the country. Her interest was piqued a few years ago when her own daughter’s elementary school opened its doors to such a club. Initially, Stewart thought the program sounded harmless enough – it billed itself as mainstream and non-denominational – but what she would soon find out about the clubs and the agenda of the well-funded organization behind them disturbed her. In her book, Stewart, in addition to examining the ramifications for the separation of church and state, lays out in great detail how these clubs use deception to attract families, how they divide communities and generally run counter to everything a public school is suppose to stand for. And as Stewart recently told NEA Today, it’s easy to draw a straight line between Good News Clubs and the political networks intent on dismantling public education.

A lot of people might hear about Good News Clubs and ask, “What’s the big deal?” How are they wrong?

I believe the Bible is worth teaching from a non-sectarian standpoint, and I believe in the free exercise of religion. The problem is that Good News Clubs, which are run by the Child Evangelism Fellowship (CEF), advertise themselves as a mainstream after-school program but they’re far from that. It pretends to offer “Bible study,” when really it’s about indoctrinating kids in a fundamentalist form of religion. They are told they must go to the “right” kind of church. They are taught that if they fail to believe or obey the tenets of this particular form of the Christian religion, they will go to hell. This is all in the curriculum. And they use deceptive tactics to attract and recruit young students and encourage them to recruit their classmates. At every Good News Club training I attended, children were offered points and prizes and sometimes even candy for recruiting their peers.

How prevalent are Good News Clubs?

There are about 3500 Good News Clubs in public schools – most of them elementary. They focus on kids in their first years of public schooling because for most kids at that age, no institution has as much authority as the public school. If it’s taught on school grounds, it then must be true. I have seen several instances, including at my daughter’s elementary school, where the Good News Clubs were offered a better space at a church immediately next door to the school, and they declined. They want to be in the school because they know that kids will think their club is endorsed by the school.

Describe how the clubs’ activities infiltrate the school?

A Good News Club flyer

Public schools are more than just bricks and mortar. They should be places where we set aside our political and religious agendas, come together and support our children. Good News Clubs preach a very different message. Children have every right to talk about their religion with their friends, but too often there have been very aggressive efforts on the part of kids who were in the club that amounted to faith-based coercion or bullying.  This happened to a daughter of a friend of mine. The teacher had to intervene and explain to the other child that the world has different religions and they should all be respected.  The girl was devastated. She actually started to cry and said “but that’s what they taught me in school.”

Again, I don’t have a problem with children discussing religious beliefs, but I do have a problem with them believing that those beliefs are sanctioned and endorsed by a public school. This is the heart of what is wrong with the Good News Clubs.


How are do these clubs undermine support for public education?

Parents shouldn’t have to get drawn into these culture wars in our schools. If it gets ugly and the community becomes divided, parents of all stripes begin to withdraw. It really harms the public school environment and undermines support for the institution as a whole. I think sowing divisions and disharmony is certainly part of the plan.

To avoid a controversy, some schools may just decide to shut down all after-school programs to avoid singling out Good News Clubs. That is not the way to go. I see that as sad diminishment of public education. One of the greater things about public schools is that they are community centers. Parents and kids need those after-school activities. Without them, support for schools can erode. So, like I say in the book, the tactic on the part of many who are behind these clubs is,  ‘if you can’t own it, break it.”

What’s the connection between Good News Clubs and the movements promoting vouchers and other so-called reforms?

Katherine Stewart

It’s all part of the same extensive network. The funders behind the Child Evangelical Fellowship have strong ties to the same groups who advocate for voucher programs and other initiatives to deprive the public education system of funding. They want to divert money away from public schools often toward private religious schools.  And these groups are often the first ones to attack teachers unions, who speak up strongly for schools. Getting rid of them makes their job a lot easier.

There’s also an alliance of convenience between those who are pushing certain measures for privateering purposes and those doing it for religious purposes. When a presidential candidate says he supports shutting the Department of Education and offers no viable alternative, he’ll be supported by people who not believe in public schools, including many on the Religious Right. It’s a very powerful and dangerous alliance.

What actions can people who are concerned about Good News Clubs take?

First, stay informed and help raise awareness. Be knowledgeable of the separation of church and state and support candidates who will work to bring better people to the judiciary. Citizens can get more involved in local school boards and advocate for policies that set certain standards for after-school clubs. We need to strengthen programs and policies that promote tolerance and civility in our schools, and broaden the discussion of bullying to include the kind of faith-based coercion that Good News Clubs can create. And always fight for public education. Look behind the curtain and find out who is behind these movements to weaken our schools. If we allow this movement to generate discontent or apathy toward public education, then its mission accomplished.

  • Susan Van Nostrand

    While I understand that some “Christian” groups can be radical in their teachings, I have seen the good side of Good News Clubs. I used to work in a rural school district where there was nothing for students to do after school but wander the streets of the town vandalizing and tormenting the elderly. We began an after-school Good News Club and we were commended by the principal for being willing to help the community and the children of the school district. Parents were also appreciative that children were given the opportunity to be involved in something worthwhile instead of getting in trouble. We did not shove any doctrine down the students’ throats. It was an opportunity for them to feel safe and have fun.

  • Carolyn R. Barnes

    I disagree with Ms. Stewart… and I don’t think the NEA has any business promoting her so called “politically correct” book. I have been a proud member of the NEA for nearly 20 years, but lately as an educator and a Christian, I am rethinking my membership. I feel like the NEA doesn’t have my best interest at heart anymore!
    Not happy with the politics of education! This is not what true teaching is suppose to be about!

  • Gillian

    I was bullied for not going to church all the time, and we didn’t have any “Good News Club” to blame.

  • The alternative to Good News Clubs in our schools is offering other other learning opportunities in their place. I have “witnessed” how this has worked in my school.

  • Debbie Brown

    I am definitely appalled that the NEA would even talk about a book like this. Good News Clubs are awesome and teach our kids wonderful values that will help them all through their lives. Kids are not required to go. Nothing they are taught is against the Bible. AND, every club myself and my kids have been involved in has always had games, prizes, snacks and fun (including girl scouts and boy scouts) because that is what kids love! For that matter, adults love these things, too! I love to have a great time and play good wholesome games and have some good snacks! I wish the NEA would quit worrying about losing kids to private schools and concentrate on using their resources to do the best job. They have way more money than private schools and unfortunately do a horrible job a lot of times at educating in what is important in school – reading, writing and mathematics.

  • Jan

    Anything can be corrupted, even the Good News Club when put in the hands of a fanatic religious person. Be very careful what you espouse, Hitler’s youth were recruited in clubs, too.

  • Kyle Gabovitz

    @ Carolyn. I could only imagine what public schools would be like without the NEA. I’m a teacher & a Christian as well but I never looked to my school to learn & understand my spirituality. I found that through my family & myself. I don’t preach it to my students because some of them believe in other religions. I do try to teach & model proper behavior & morality.
    Ms. Stewart is correct in pointing out that a lot of the religious right is trying to undermine public schools. While they’re are problems with our public schools is is borderline sociopathic to want to blow the whole system up.

  • scott crocker

    Why dont they have normal clubs like chess club, drama club, band, science club.
    Religion should be out of our schools unless they are going to do all religions and atheism, we dont take science labs to church!
    On another note, many studies have been done on this and it concludes the more religious, the less intellegent! Keep your religion out of my school.

  • jaymadison

    Ms. Stewart’s analysis is on the money. Groups such Good News Club and the Fellowship of Christian Athletes have just one purpose – to push Christian/Protestatent/Fundamentalist dogma on every student they come in contact with. They brazenly and knowingly violate the law, daring parents to challenge them. They are a cancer growing in the public schoold

  • Wayne Hobelmann

    I started teaching in 1961, at that time the US was number 1 in Math and Science through out the world. The Good News Clubs is an effort by people who believe in God to put God back in the public schools. The Supreme Court in 1973 ruled in favor of an Athiest and made it more difficult to pray in public schools. In the late 60’s after protest we replaced God’s type of authority in schools with student rights. The ten commandments that was established by the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob are believed to be true by Christians, Jews and Moslems. But our Government, our Schools, and the NEA are now saying the some of God’s commandments are not necessarily true and are replacing them with various rights which they claim to be first amendment rights. In Duet 28 which is in the Christian, Jewish and Moslem Bibles states what happens to those who believe God’s commandments are true and to those that choose not to follow them. For 200 years we read the Bible and prayed in public schools. The last 40 years we have put prayer out of schools and replaced some of the commandments for rights and we have fallen from 1st in Math to 24th in Math in the world. We have become a nation that owed no other nations any debt to now owing China $7 Trillion. This chapter, Deut. 28 very vividly describes what’s happening to the USA. Teaching students without God may help them for 40, 50 60 years in this life. Teaching them with God helps them in this life and throughout eternity where with God is love, without him is hate. I would rather have some one warn me about hell and avoid it and rather not warn me and have an eternity of misery without love. Separation of Church and State is not in the Constitution. Read the 1st Amendment. God has made Himself real to me through reading the Bible and teaching Math for 51 years. These clubs such as FCA do not want to force their ideas on you, but simple want to share the Joy, Love, and Peace of God that they have with others and make this world a better place to live giving God’s grace to others rather than judgment which is often misinterpreted.

  • moisese

    • The Equal Access Act became law in 1984 allowing religious clubs to use public school facilities on equal bases with other clubs. Child Evangelism Fellowship (CEF) had no role, no advocacy, no lobbying of Congress whatever in the passage of this law.
    • The law was upheld by the Supreme Court in Good News Clubs vs. Milford Central Schools (2001).
    • Any religious organization of any stripe has the same right to access as CEF.
    • CEF is entirely a-political and has conspired with no one. Ms. Stewart is confused about the difference between a conspiracy and a movement. People on the local level choose to sponsor Good News Clubs or not at their own expense at their own initiative.
    • CEF has no desire, policy, or practices which seek to undermine public education. There are no funds given or accepted by CEF for that purpose. CEF’s purpose in sponsoring Good News Clubs is Biblical literacy and the redemption offered therein.
    • Attendance at Good News Clubs is entirely voluntary and parents must sign permission slips for their child to attend.
    • Further, Ms. Stewart did not contact or attempt to contact any of the leadership of CEF in the writing of her book to verify or clarify anything she asserts.

  • MarkR

    This what I know about Good News Club. The children MUST have parental permission to attend and can discontinue going to club at anytime during the school year. All flyers I’ve seen expressly communicate that the club is neither endorsed or sponsored by the school or school district. Parents are welcome to attend to observe everything taught at the club. Parents can become involved as a volunteer once the proper screening has been done and do teaching once proper training has been received. Every club is run in a very structured organized fashion. All school administrators and teachers are welcome at the club. The club fosters positive behavior on campus helps children recognize that they can stand shoulder to shoulder with other students who desire positive behavior. Public schools are public facilities that are used after hours by many groups including the Boy Scouts, the Girl Scouts, the YMCA, tutoring organizations, etc, anyone who is willing to meet the criteria set forth by the district. Sometimes the facilities are offered for free and sometimes the facilities are rented but the Good News Club never gets special treatment, just equal treatment.

  • Jay Madison

    moisese, Katherine Stewart had conversations with persons at many levels of the Good News Clubs and Child Evangelism Fellowship. She even attended a CEF conference to discuss these issues.

    CEF leadership was extremely reluctant to talk with Katherine Stewart. She tried.

  • Stephanie

    Unfortunately, Ms. Stewart, you have not done “due diligence” as a journalist because much of your information is incorrect and your opinions, just that, opinions with little to no real credibility. I am a public school educator and worked for Rockwood School District for 9 years. I am also a published essayist and interested in The Truth and responsible journalism (as I would teach to my students).

    The Good News Club program provides complete and full disclosure regarding its practices, including a paragraph in the Parent Permission Form which states, “The United States Constitution requires schools to respect the right of all external organizations to distribute flyers to students at school if the school permits any such organization to distribute flyers. Accordingly, the school cannot discriminate among groups wishing to distribute flyers at school and does not endorse the content of any flyer distributed at school. The school encourages parents to assist their children in making choices appropriate for them. This is not an activity of the school or the School District.”

    Although, you expected many to read your NEA Today publication, you failed to read all of the content in the Parent Permission slip and report in your writing accordingly. Also listed on the permission slip, “Parents are welcome to attend with child(ren).” This is in addition to the full and complete disclosure of the church and organization who sponsor and serve in this club, their contact information, as well as what will be taught, “Bible Lessons, Missionary Stories, Scripture Memory, Biblical Principles…”

    Furthermore, it is the intent of the club to encourage the attendees to respect all authority (teachers, administrators, parents), each other, and their learning environment. The club curriculum also parallels the school’s Character Education Program, even teaching some of the same Character Words: Respect, Courage, Responsibility, etc. Additionally, the club provides an opportunity for the community to be involved in and build a sense of ownership and pride for their local public school system. Building a good community-school rapport is actually part of MO DESE standards which include “4.1 Bring together family, community and resources to support learning” and “4.3 Mobilize community resources to impact student learning” ( Good News Clubs, Boy and Girl Scouts, YMCA programs and other organizations all help to bring families and the community together in order to support the learning and development of the students as well as to create a positive learning environment. Good News Clubs and their supporters do not feel “entitled” anymore than the scouting and YMCA programs.

    You gave one example of a student who misunderstood (which happens with children) or possibly simply used Good News Club as a good excuse for a poor choice (which also happens with children). In my 9 years of public school education, I worked closely with the Anti-tobacco and drug-free school initiatives, even sponsoring one of the clubs; and yet, a student in my own class who was caught with drugs in his locker used the excuse that “the school did not teach him that drugs were bad”. His parents also used this excuse in court, trying to smear the public school district. However, I don’t believe anyone in this day and age who knows anything about the public school system could say with certainty that our public schools do not teach students about the consequences of poor choices, including drug use. I give this example to bring to light that with your one example of a misinformed child, there are many other children in clubs all over, who, having been encouraged in club to make right choices, are actually making their schools better places to learn and grow.

  • John

    I am sorry, Jay, but the “Moises” you addressed is the VP for USA Ministries at CEF. I also have a working relationship at the top levels of CEF and have thoroughly read Kathrine Stewart’s book. Though she did attend a CEF national conference without identifying herself which she discusses in her book, she has made no attempt to contact or interview anyone in leadership at CEF at the conference, before it or since. She quotes no interviews with any of them in her book because she spoke to none. The fact that she did not belies the intent of the book. The entire conspiracy theory is fabricated from whole cloth. I know it is hard to believe that someone would go to such lengths to write and promote her assertions, but it is the case. (My two sisters and one brother-in-law are public school teachers, btw. I have no issues with the NEA, just this odd book).

  • Rebekah Becky Majors-Manley


  • Stephanie

    BTW – the picture with the balloons is NOT the permission slip that CEF and the Good News Clubs use. I have no idea where you got that. The official permission slip has the copyrighted logo [no balloons], states the name of the group and provides full disclosure stating specifically “Bible stories”, not “exciting stories”.

  • Pingback: Religious Right using after-school clubs to undermine public education, says author | Education Votes()

  • Rick Manly

    What is the NEA’s position on the sexualization of children, including elementary school children, via Planned Parenthood and other so-called “progressive” organizations?

  • Eric Stone

    The religious right is committed to the destruction of the public school system in the USA because its secular character undermines their ability to indoctrinate children with fears of supernatural revenge for disobedience. It is part of their large program to destroy all of our secular institutions and replace them with Christian biblical “analogues.” Brava for Ms. Stewart’s brave attempt to reveal the true motives of the Good News Club, a key program in this effort.

  • Val E. Forge

    I wonder how the NEA would feel about a “Good News Club” if the book taught from was the Koran?